Newcastle manager Alan Pardew says referee admitted David Luiz mistake

• Chelsea defender shown yellow card in 3-0 win
• Pardew says Mike Dean admitted his mistake

The Newcastle United manager, Alan Pardew, has said that the referee Mike Dean has admitted he should have sent off the Chelsea defender David Luiz during the Premier League match at St James’ Park on Saturday.

The Brazilian was shown a yellow card for a fourth-minute challenge on Demba Ba, in a match that Chelsea’s won 3-0.

Pardew said after the game the official had told him, at half-time, that he did not show a red card because Ba did not have the ball under control.

Speaking on Sky Sports on Sunday, Pardew said Dean’s opinion of the incident had changed after seeing it again.

Pardew said: “I have got no problem with the referee yesterday, he made a mistake. Actually, he has since after the game seen it again and said to me, ‘I made a mistake, he should have been sent off’.

“At half-time yesterday, his opinion was different, but his opinion would have been altered if his assistant referee had done his job, in my opinion. When I saw the referee at half-time, I said, ‘Why did you not send him off?’ He said to me, ‘He didn’t have control of the ball.’

“Well, how can you have control of the ball when the guy is knocking you over? There is no way the goalie is getting to the ball, but the bigger problem I have got is with the linesman on this occasion, because I was looking at the linesman. The linesman can see that – he didn’t flag, he didn’t go mad, he didn’t do anything, so Mike Dean is making that decision from 40 yards away.

“If the linesman is waving his flag and suggesting, ‘You know what, this is an incident here,’ and they have got their little mics…

“It would have altered the game, down to 10 men, Chelsea, the pressure they were under. I wouldn’t have lost my centre-half [Fabricio Collocini] to injury because we were forcing the game. I had people charging around trying to get back a situation when we would have been in control of the game. Not only do I lose the game, but I have lost two players through injury. I’m still angry.”

Newcastle had the benefit of a controversial decision at Manchester United last weekend, when they were awarded a penalty for a Rio Ferdinand challenge on Hatem Ben Arfa after the referee, Mike Jones, had originally awarded a corner. That game finished 1-1.

Pardew said: “The problem we have got in this country is that it’s something like the budget, I am told, £8m for the referees, everything – assistants, assessors, the whole budget. Now when you think about how much money is thrown at this game, that can’t be right.

“The training for the referees is about £30,000, believe it or not. We have got assistant referees who are not full-time, so we are going to have this problem unless we say assistant referees are professional. The referee has then got a unit that’s trained, that trains together, that works together, that knows each other, who can deal with those situations because they are dealing with them when they are training in the week. Unless we do something like that, it isn’t going to improve.”

Alan PardewNewcastle UnitedChelseaguardian.co.uk

Newcastle seethe after Chelsea’s David Luiz escapes a red card

• Defender only booked after early foul on goalbound Demba Ba
• André Villas-Boas apologises for fitness coach’s celebration

The real Chelsea made a dramatic return at Newcastle with an emphatic win that could have been by double the score, though in the best traditions of the club the 3-0 victory came with double the usual amount of controversy.

First Newcastle were annoyed when Mike Dean failed to dismiss David Luiz for a professional foul in the fifth minute. Then, when Salomon Kalou clinched victory a minute from time, the home bench was incensed by José Mario Rocha, Chelsea’s fitness coach, invading their technical area to celebrate provocatively in their faces.

David Luiz should almost certainly have gone for hauling down Demba Ba to deny a clear scoring opportunity, and Alan Pardew felt with some justification that the outcome could have been different had Newcastle been playing 10 men. “I thought the referee was going to produce a red card,” the Newcastle manager said. “I don’t really understand why he didn’t. I was really angry, and I’m sure if it had happened to one of our players he would have had to walk.

“I asked Mike Dean about it at half-time and he said he wasn’t sure Ba had control of the ball. I’ll have to look in the rulebook about that because it’s a new one on me. It really hurts, because with the atmosphere and the crowd it could have been a completely different afternoon. Chelsea would have struggled.”

André Villas-Boas did not attempt to defend the decision. “It was a major incident, but the referee made a decision that went our way,” he said. “I am not going to apologise for that, after all the decisions that have gone against us this season, offsides at Old Trafford and penalties against Bayer Leverkusen and Liverpool.

“Maybe a big decision went our way, but we play even better with 10 or nine men anyway. We are making good progress now and I want to praise all my players for their amazing fighting spirit. I don’t know why they have ever been questioned.”

Villas-Boas did apologise for Rocha’s behaviour. “I

FA charges André Villas-Boas of Chelsea with improper conduct

• Chelsea manager charged for referee comments
• Villas-Boas criticised Chris Foy after QPR defeat

André Villas-Boas has been charged with improper conduct over comments made about the referee Chris Foy after Chelsea’s 1-0 defeat at QPR last month.

At Loftus Road, the Chelsea manager admitted that he had been “very aggressive” towards Foy, and that he had accused the official, who sent off two of his players, of failing to treat the teams equally.

He said: “The ref was poor, very, very poor. And it reflected in the result. I spoke to him at the end and I was very aggressive to him. I don’t care if he’s OK or not. Everyone can have a bad day, but this was not a bad day for us. It was a good day for us and a bad day for the referee. A couple of decisions are right, yellow cards for sure, but I think he lost it before and was card happy towards the team. I’m not happy with the difference of treatment. I don’t think the same treatment was applied.

“Apart from the fourth official, the other three were led by the emotions of the crowd and couldn’t deal with a game like this.

“Three of the games played by Chelsea were influenced by the referee, and this is not Premier League level. You have to trust human error, but it’s a big pattern for us. Things are not going our way. Conspiracy theories can lead to bans and lead to you calling us cry babies, and we’re not. But it keeps happening. We’re showing commitment and strength. Hopefully, things will go our way, referee decisions going our way.”

On Friday, a Football Association statement said: “Chelsea manager André Villas-Boas has been charged with improper conduct by the FA, following media comments he made about the match official after his side’s match at Queens Park Rangers on 23 October 2011. Villas-Boas has until 4pm on 15 November 2011 to respond to the charge.”

André Villas-BoasChelseaThe FAguardian.co.uk