Chelsea’s failure to nullify Wayne Rooney proved their undoing | David Pleat

It was Wayne Rooney, more than anyone else, who rocked Chelsea, as Manchester United stormed back to snatch a point

After an ordinary first half, the game exploded after the catalyst of Chelsea’s third, fortuitous goal. Juan Mata’s great volley, created by his fellow Spaniard Fernando Torres, had lifted Chelsea’s spirits but their team, devoid of core players – Ashley Cole, Frank Lampard, John Terry and Didier Drogba – fumbled their way forwards after Sir Alex Ferguson’s changes worked to perfection.

His alterations were aided by André Villas-Boas’s decision to substitute Daniel Sturridge, the one player who could create a pressure point for the home team, teasing Patrice Evra to the first goal and then drawing the Manchester United left-back into committing a yellow-card offence. Without his trickery in wide areas, Torres was even more bereft of support. In truth, Torres’s approach play was better than in recent games but in delaying a golden opportunity to score when Chelsea were 3-2 up he displayed a lack of confidence. Chelsea never got into advanced areas down the left because the left-footed Florent Malouda was too narrow, particularly in the first half. Mata, also a left-footer, played his scheming role more centrally, and the right-footed José Bosingwa was trapped when advancing into the middle third.

Torres did not receive one cross from the left to attack from an advanced position and his goal famine goes on.

It was Wayne Rooney, more than anyone else, who rocked Chelsea as United stormed back. Picking up balls from all areas he needed to be man-marked. His energy is incredible and his desire to be accurate in all he does is admirable. His finding of space is so intelligent and his forward runs, with or without the ball, exemplary.

Michael Essien, understandably lacking energy, might have attempted to sit on him had Ramires been available to play alongside Raul Meireles. They needed someone with enough energy and discipline to nail Rooney.

Paul Scholes, in the centre, was clinical and Ryan Giggs, calm and classy on the left, held sway. The Blues lacked the confidence to keep the ball and gain passages of possession to take the sting out of the game. They got submerged into the ebb and flow, but they desperately needed to hold the game as United threw caution to the wind. Ferguson had a field day. Even David de

Manchester United’s David de Gea shows true worth in Spanish duel

The young goalkeeper illustrated his talent with a superb save from Chelsea’s Juan Mata in added time to preserve a point

David De Gea, whose fitness to succeed Peter Schmeichel and Edwin van der Sar is a constant source of debate, reimbursed a chunk of the £18.3m paid for his services by Manchester United when he preserved the 3-3 scoreline so dramatically secured by his team‑mates with a save that conspicuously illustrated the talent identified in the young Spaniard by Sir Alex Ferguson and his scouts.

In the first minute of added time Paul Scholes obstructed David Luiz 25 yards from the United goal, leading Howard Webb to award a free‑kick. Juan Mata, who had played a part in each of the goals that had given Chelsea a 3-0 lead, hit a fantastic 25‑yard free‑kick that was arrowing into the top right-hand corner until De

Chelsea v Manchester United | Jacob Steinberg

• Hit F5 to refresh or turn on the automatic widget below
• Email your thoughts to jacob.steinberg.casual@guardian.co.uk
• Follow Jacob on Twitter, if that’s your thing
• Get the latest tables and more in our stats centre

Manchester United haven’t won at Chelsea in the league since 20 April 2002. Ten years. A miserable record, especially as Chelsea have been managed by Avram Grant in that time. And to think people quibble about Tottenham’s record at Old Trafford. These are meant to be the champions of England, and they can’t even win at a ground where Chelsea didn’t lose for 86 matches, a run spanning four years and eight months. Oh.

Only four players, two on each side, remain from that match. United won 3-0, a victory that wasn’t enough to stop Arsenal finally sealing the league title at Old Trafford a couple of weeks later. No prizes for guessing which players we’re looking for here. For Chelsea, it’s former England captain John Terry and Frank Lampard. For United, it’s Ryan Giggs and Paul Scholes, who gave Lampard a lesson that afternoon and may be about to give him another one today. Scholes got United on their way, scoring a trademark 25-yarder, a fine way to end a season which began with him being messed about following the arrival of Juan Sebastian Veron. There have been a few occasions heralded as the end of Scholes, but here he still is, running the show against Liverpool at last weekend and against Stoke on Tuesday, like a dad pulling the strings in a game with his kids down the park. “Och, he’s got feathers in his feet,” purred Sir Alex Ferguson after the 2-0 win over Tony Pulis’s side.

Still, the return of Scholes from retirement last month, as romantic as it is, does demonstrate the problems facing United, who decided the best way to replace Paul Scholes is with Paul Scholes. Accept no lesser imitations and all that, but the lack of care given to their midfield over the last few years is the major factor holding this side back from truly challenging the best in Europe. In that context, it is remarkable that they are still keeping up with Manchester City, a bit like when you chop garlic and the smell follows you around for days. Despite not playing that well against Stoke, there was never really any doubt that United would eventually find a way.

They haven’t had many better opportunities to end their dismal run at Stamford Bridge than this. There remains the possibility that Chelsea might suddenly rediscover their former swagger at some point this season, but it’s looking increasingly unlikely. If United need an example of the dangers of standing still, look no further. Where the blame lies for Chelsea’s slump isn’t immediately clear. On the one hand, we constantly hear of a squad full of difficult characters who need taking down a peg or two and who haven’t won nearly as much as their egos would suggest.

Add to that an inconsistent transfer policy – it’s hard to name too many obvious successful signings since 2006 – and constantly changing managers, and it would appear that Andre Villas-Boas needs time and support from above. Don’t hold your breath. On the other hand, even with some of the old guard sent off to the glue factory, Chelsea still don’t have any obvious style or philosophy on the pitch. With all this talk of former players, now wouldn’t be the worst time for the old Fernando Torres to come out of hiding.

Teams: Were any of the Chelsea substitutes alive the last time United won at Stamford Bridge?

Chelsea (4-3-3): Cech; Ivanovic, Cahill, Luiz, Bosingwa; Essien, Meireles, Malouda; Sturridge, Torres, Mata. Subs: Turnbull, Ferreira, Bertrand, Hutchinson, Romeu, Piazon, Lukaku.

Manchester United (4-4-2): De Gea; Rafael, Evans, Ferdinand, Evra: Valencia Giggs, Carrick, Young; Rooney, Welbeck. Subs: Amos, Fabio, Park, Berbatov, Pogba, Hernandez, Scholes.

Referee: Howard Webb.

Premier League 2011-12ChelseaManchester UnitedPremier LeagueJacob Steinberg
guardian.co.uk